Caplinger’s Story

In 2013 Andrew, his wife, Courtney, and dad, Nick, founded Caplinger’s Fresh Catch. We are just what our name says. With deliveries coming in every single day, you can be sure you’ll always get the freshest catch that there is.

Caplinger’s Fresh Catch Seafood Market began with a vision to make fresh, quality seafood available in the Midwest. Andrew Caplinger gained much of his knowledge from working alongside his father and business partner, Nick Caplinger. Nick owned and operated the 56th Street Fish Market and preceded this venture by starting O’Mallia’s and Mr. D’S grocery store’s seafood programs. With their community-centered business model, the Caplinger family has been in the seafood industry for over three decades. Caplinger’s employees have more than 150 years of combined seafood knowledge. Therefore, you can always expect to leave with the confidence that you received the best instruction to ensure a tremendous culinary seafood experience.

At Caplingers, we debunk the misconception that you have to travel to the coast to get quality seafood. Come and see why we have won both local and national recognition as one of the best seafood markets in the country. 

Our People

Amy

Office Manager
All Locations

Vicente

Store Manager
Shadeland Ave.

Juan

Kitchen Manager
Shadeland Ave.

Genaro

Food Service
Shadeland Ave.

Mario

Customer Service
Shadeland Ave.

Miriam

Customer Service
Shadeland Ave.

Becky

Cashier
Shadeland Ave.

Seth

Store Manager
Whitestown

Phil

Kitchen Manager
Whitestown

Andrew

Customer Service
Whitestown

Tony

Store Manager
Pendleton Pike

Eloy

Food Prep Manager
Pendleton Pike

Maria

Food Prep
Pendleton Pike

Tomas

Food Prep
Pendleton Pike

Leonor

Food Prep
Pendleton Pike

Derek

Food Service
Pendleton Pike

Mike

Store Manager
South Side

Reward Program

Our Rewards Program will be changing to a new platform very soon.  We strongly encourage you to use your points towards rewards.  If you are not able to use them they will not automatically load into the new system.  Feel free to reach out to us with an email and we will transfer your points into the new system. You can send your request to caplingersfreshcatch@gmail.com

Earn 1 Point for every $1 spent!

Please note that reward points can be earned and redeemed in-store only.

75 points
choice of one free item (1/4 lb shrimp, 1/4 lb clams, 1/4 lb oysters, key lime pie slice, cake slice)
 
100 points
choice of one free item (clam chowda, shrimp cocktail, $10 off any FRESH seafood purchase) 
 
250 points
choice of one free item (blue crab melt sandwich only, lobsta roll sandwich only, Caplinger’s Special dinner, catfish dinner, calamari steak dinner, cod dinner, fish & shrimp dinner, fish & chicken dinner, shrimp dinner, tilapia dinner)
 
500 points
25% off entire purchase ($75 max discount) 
 
1,000 points
50% off entire purchase ( $150 max discount) 
 
5,000 points
$250 gift card 
 
10,000 points
$500 gift card
We're Hiring