Place your order online before you arrive!

Our commitment is to serve quality seafood made to order with fresh ingredients and homemade breading and sauces.

Sandwiches

Sandwiches are served fried or grilled with your choice of fixins of tartar sauce, lettuce, onion, tomato, and pickles.

Caplinger's Special

Sandwich only. Our #1 selling sandwich. Mild and flaky whitefish cooked to perfection. Great fried or grilled.

Smoked Tuna Salad

Our "almost famous" homemade smoked tuna salad served on a fresh toasted bun with your choice of fixins.

Catfish Fillet

Our catfish is all raised right here in the USA. great fried, good grilled.

Soft Shell Crab

Two whole soft-shell crabs lightly breaded, fried & served on a fresh toasted bun with your choice of fixins.

Salmon Fillet

Fresh Atlantic salmon grilled to perfection with your choice of seasonings and toppings.

Cod Loin

We use the loin cut of the cod making for a tasty flaky marvel of the seafood world.

Calamari Steak

Not your typical Midwesterners sandwich. Very mild in flavor and a great texture. Try it and you will LOVE it.

Chicken Breast

A boneless, skinless chicken breast fried or grilled & served on a fresh toasted bun with your choice of fixins.

Tilapia Fillet

A "can't miss". Tilapia is a tender white flaky fish that goes great with anything. Great fried or grilled.

Lobsta Roll

Our “lobsta” rolls are made with claw and knuckle meat and tossed with just a few other fresh secret ingredients and piled into one of our fresh toasted locally baked rolls.

Oyster Po Boy

A quarter pound of fried oysters topped with lettuce, onion, pickle, tomato, and remoulade sauce tucked inside a fresh toasted hoagie roll.

Clam Po Boy

A quarter pound of fried clams topped with lettuce, onion, pickle, tomato, and remoulade sauce tucked inside a fresh toasted hoagie roll.

Shrimp Po Boy

A quarter pound of fried shrimp topped with lettuce, onion, pickle, tomato, and remoulade sauce tucked inside a fresh toasted hoagie roll.

Ocean Perch

Fried to perfection. Our ocean perch is all either US or Canadian product. Not available grilled.

Whiting Fillet

Great moderately flavored whitefish. Only available fried.

Pork Tenderloin

A fresh pork tenderloin cut in-house, fried or grilled, and served on a freshly toasted bun with your choice of fixins.

All dinners are served with your choice of 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies, and sauce.

Caplinger's Special

Our #1 Seller! This dinner is served with 2 pieces of basa, 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and sauce.

Catfish Fillet

Fried or grilled to perfection and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and a sauce.

Chicken Breast

Two boneless, skinless chicken breasts fried or grilled and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies, and a sauce.

Alligator Tail

"It tastes like chicken." Really it does. Fried or grilled to perfection and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and a sauce.

Calamari Steak

Fried or grilled to perfection and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and a sauce.

Fish & Shrimp

1 piece of basa and ¼ lb shrimp fried or grilled to perfection and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and a sauce.

Fish & Chicken

A fillet of basa and a chicken breast fried or grilled and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies, and a sauce.

Ocean Perch

Fried to perfection and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies, and a sauce.

Salmon Fillet

Grilled to perfection and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and a sauce.

Whiting Fillet

Fried to perfection and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and a sauce.

Cod Loin

Fried or grilled to perfection and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and a sauce.

Tilapia Fillet

Fried or grilled to perfection and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and a sauce.

Soft Shell Crab

Four whole soft-shell crabs lightly breaded & fried and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies, and a sauce.

Shrimp

14 to 16 pieces. Fried or grilled to perfection and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and a sauce.

Crab Cake

Crab cakes cooked to perfection and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and a sauce.

Frog Legs

Fried to perfection and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies, and a sauce.

Oyster Dinner

A half-pound of oysters breaded & fried and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies, and a sauce.

Lobsta Roll

Served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies, and a sauce.

Buffalo Clam Strip

Fried to perfection and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies, and a sauce.

Kids Meal

1 piece of fish or chicken cut into bites and served with 1 regular side and a regular drink.

The Platter

1 fillet of basa, ¼ lb shrimp, and ¼ lb clam strips fried or grilled to perfection and served with 2 sides, 2 hushpuppies and 2 sauces. (clam strips will always be fried).

We will cook any fish from the cases at NO charge! Taxes apply.

Dinners

Melts

Sandwiches are served fried or grilled with your choice of fixins of tartar sauce, lettuce, onion, tomato, and pickles.

Blue Crab Melt

Blue crab meat piled into one of our fresh baked rolls topped with mayo and mounds of Mozzarella and Provolone cheese melted to perfection.

Lobster Melt

Our amazing lobster roll mix, sautéed onions and peppers piled into a fresh roll and covered with a blanket of melted Mozzarella and Provolone cheese.

Tuna Melt

Blue crab meat piled into one of our fresh baked rolls topped with mayo and mounds of Mozzarella and Provolone cheese melted to perfection.

Seafood Philly Melt

Blue crab, lobster, and shrimp all piled high in a fresh roll with sautéed onions, peppers, remoulade sauce, and a blanket of melted Mozzarella and Provolone cheese.

Screamin' Crab Melt

Blue crab meat screamin' with sriracha loaded into one of our fresh baked rolls topped with sauteed onions and peppers, then covered in a blanket of Mozzarella and Provolone cheese

Screamin' Lobster Melt

Lobster Meat screamin' with sriracha loaded into one of our fresh baked rolls topped with sautéed onions and peppers, then covered in a blanket of Mozzarella / Provolone cheese …

Add an appetizer to any meal to take your seafood experience to the next level.

Calamari Fries

Tender strips of calamari breaded and fried to golden perfection. Served with your choice of sauce.

Gator Bites

½ lb of alligator meat.

Crab Cakes

We make our crab cakes with lump crab meat and just a few other fresh and simple ingredients. They are served with our homemade remoulade sauce.

Frog Legs

1 lb of frog legs.

Fried Oysters

¼ lb of fried oysters.

Shrimp

6 to 8 pieces served with a sauce.

Fried Clam Strips

¼ lb of thicker cut clam strip and it is served with your choice of sauce.

Clam Chowda

This is our homemade New England style clam chowder. It is rich and creamy with lots of clams.

Shrimp Cocktail (5pc)

Our signature cocktail sauce and 5 pieces of jumbo cooked shrimp with a lemon wedge.

Oysters on the Half Shell

6 or 12 pieces. These are Blue Point Oysters shucked and on the half shell served with your choice of sauce and a lemon wedge.

Basa Fillet

Single fillet of Basa (Caplinger's Special).

Catfish Fillet

Single fillet of catfish.

Chicken Breast

Single chicken breast.

Calamari Steak

Single calamari steak.

Ocean Perch Fillet

Single ocean perch fillet.

Salmon Fillet

Single salmon fillet.

Whiting Fillet

Single whiting fillet.

Cod Fillet

Single cod fillet.

Appetizers

Sides

Each dinner includes your choice of 2 sides. Sides may be added to orders that do not include sides.

Collard Greens

The best you will ever eat.

Chipotle Slaw

With just a hint of spice and the smokiness of the chipotle, this is not your typical slaw.

Red Beans & Rice

A southern favorite. Our red beans and rice are paired with andouille sausage, giving it a nice kick.

Sweet Corn

Corn on the cob plain or sprinkled with Old Bay Seasoning.

Mac & Cheese

We make our mac and cheese with a blend of cheeses and finish it off in the oven.

Green Beans

We cook our green beans in beef broth giving them a great flavor.

Candied Yams

Yams caramelized in brown sugar, butter, and a special blend of spices.

Buffalo Fries

Our fries are a round cut that has a slightly spicy coating going perfectly with all dinners.

Hushpuppies

These tasty little morsels are a staple with any fried fish meal.

Baked Beans

Our baked beans are sweet and tangy.

Fried Okra

A southern favorite. Lightly breaded and fried. Great with a side of remoulade sauce.

Pineapple Bread Pudding

Our rich and sticky homemade pineapple bread pudding is drizzled with our velvety vanilla cream sauce to warm your belly. Enough to share, or not.

Pie by the Slice

Choose between key lime pie, Wick's sugar cream pie, or Wick's pecan pie,

Cake by the Slice

Choose from our selection of cakes, including cheesecake, carrot cake, limoncello mascarpone cake, and chocolate cake.

Whole Key Lime Pie

Our smooth & tangy Homemade Key Lime Pie is crafted with Nellie & Joe's Key West Lime Juice.

Desserts

Drinks

We Proudly Serve

{Fountain & Bottled Drinks}

Please Note: All menu prices are subject to change without notice.

Reward Program

Our Rewards Program will be changing to a new platform very soon.  We strongly encourage you to use your points towards rewards.  If you are not able to use them they will not automatically load into the new system.  Feel free to reach out to us with an email and we will transfer your points into the new system. You can send your request to caplingersfreshcatch@gmail.com

Earn 1 Point for every $1 spent!

Please note that reward points can be earned and redeemed in-store only.

75 points
choice of one free item (1/4 lb shrimp, 1/4 lb clams, 1/4 lb oysters, key lime pie slice, cake slice)
 
100 points
choice of one free item (clam chowda, shrimp cocktail, $10 off any FRESH seafood purchase) 
 
250 points
choice of one free item (blue crab melt sandwich only, lobsta roll sandwich only, Caplinger’s Special dinner, catfish dinner, calamari steak dinner, cod dinner, fish & shrimp dinner, fish & chicken dinner, shrimp dinner, tilapia dinner)
 
500 points
25% off entire purchase ($75 max discount) 
 
1,000 points
50% off entire purchase ( $150 max discount) 
 
5,000 points
$250 gift card 
 
10,000 points
$500 gift card

Online Ordering:

PLEASE BE AWARE THAT WE MUST PREPARE ORDERS IN THE ORDER THAT THEY ARE RECEIVED. THIS INCLUDES CALL-IN AND WALK-IN ORDERS. THE TIME QUOTED TO YOU ONLINE DOES NOT ACCOUNT FOR THIS ADDITIONAL VOLUME.

ONLINE ORDERING MAY BE UNAVAILABLE AT TIMES DUE TO A HIGHER VOLUME OF WALK-IN CUSTOMER ORDERS. WE WILL RESUME ONLINE ORDERS AS SOON AS WE’RE ABLE TO. THANK YOU FOR YOUR UNDERSTANDING.

We're Hiring